June 13, 2007

The Sales Apprentice: Sales training tips from the hit TV show, The Final

After last week’s flashback to what interviewing might have been like in “Life on Mars” with it’s sexist questioning tactics aimed at proving woman with children have to make their case to work, tonight’s episode was back to business as normal with a task..

This was billed as the “head to head” between Simon and Kristina but turned out to be more of a battle of egos between many of the “bit “ players. This was Rosencrantz and Guildenstern centre stage and it wasn’t pretty. Not so many sales training tips tonight but many personal development and career lessons for how not to achieve success in life, business and sales.

The specialist task tonight was to come up with a landmark for London. SAS wanted a conceptual idea for the replacement of a £120m building he had just bought. It has to be meaningful, innovative and … make him some money. They were not actually going to “do” this project – it’s all about creativity and in 4 days time they are going to have to present their vision to an audience of “top” property executives.

SAS is looking at this as a test of their organizational skills, how they can run a team of people and how creative they are. Their teams will be be made up of ex-apprentices. This should be a spectacular car crash of personalities if nothing else. Simon picks Tre, Rory, Jadine and Lohit whilst Kristina chooses Natalie, Naomi, Adam and Paul.

Sales training tip: Sometime teams have history together. Sometimes there are frictions at play. Sometimes different sales personalities do not “gel” well together. As a sales leader or sales manager your role is to get the most out of the team that you have. How can you arrange teams to get the most out of the individuals and the team as a whole?

Simon and Tre are the first to come up with an idea. They want to work with a “boat” theme. Jadine and Rory are quick to start muttering in the corner. Rory thinks this is idea is uninspiring and Jadine is willing to play along.

This kind of behaviour is common in underperforming sales teams. How many times do we see this kind of behaviour? What can we do to stop it? How can you prevent it? This kind of behaviour is childish, immature and counter-productive. It’s not something that can be countenanced and it needs to be nipped in the bud sharpish.

Meanwhile Adam and Naomi are sent off to look for design ideas. When Kristina later asks Adam for feedback, Natalie and Paul exchange knowing glances. The ideas are rejected. And there is my problem with this whole show…

Tonight had nothing to do with business and nothing to do with team work. What it did have a lot to do with was ego, personality clashes and “one up manship”.

Upstairs Simon and Tre try to float their boat idea. Rory looks unimpressed and dives in with his own vision. Rory even admits that he wants to upset Tre… just not so much that he punches him. Wow! I must have missed out with the teams I have run and managed. What’s wrong with working together and getting on with the job in hand?

Next day the two teams sit down with the experts to talk about their design ideas. Paul and Adam discover almost immediately that the chosen Phoenix design agreed by Kristina and them the night before is too formalistic. So they change it. They don’t, however, bother to tell Kristina until it is too late for her to do anything about it.

Still at the house, Simon calls a meeting to lay into his team. Yesterday was a shambles he declares. Stop sitting around like children and get on with it. Rory says that there is no incentive for them to work hard. Really? You were thrown out for looking like a duck in week 2, you’re on national TV with a chance to redeem yourself but you can’t see any incentive? Get real!

Sales training tip: When I do sales consultancy, working on the motivation and dynamics of proactive sales teams, individuals often say that there is little or no incentive for them to work harder. I find this hard to swallow. For sure, sometimes the management and (external) incentives could be better thought out but ultimately these are the excuses of sales wannabees not sales winners.

Sales winners are self-motivated and self-driven as are successful individuals in all walks of life. If you make excuses such as these, challenge yourself to stop blaming others for your own lack of motivation and get out there and find a way to motivate yourself!

Rory meanwhile is on his soap box about Tre being self-taught and not having a grounding in design. Ironically, Rory himself later decides to choreograph a group of dancers to introduce their presentation and has to admit to Tre that he has no experience or skills in this area.

Meanwhile, Kristina is doing “due diligence” on her building, finding out what the exact split is between commerical and residential that will allow her to recoup maximum revenues. After a conversation with Paul on the phone about the changed design that he had not told her about she questions whether she can trust him or not. She conculdes that maybe she can’t.

Sales training tip: Trust is essential in sales and selling. Without trust, sales success will not happen. In sales training seminars, many salespeople tell me that they think that selling is all about being “friends” with their clients. Interestingly, I would suggest that personal rapport without trust does not carry over into sales and business scenarios. So, I can have gone to the same school as you and we can chat about that happily but the moment I move to business conversations you sense the change and rapport is broken.

What we need is trust. Trust and credibility. Two qualities that seem somewhat lacking in many of our Machiavellian (…as pertaining to Niccolo Machiavelli, Florentine Statesman, or denoting the political principles of craftiness and duplicity advocated by him) business wannabees.

After a day of preparations our two teams arrive to make their presentation to 100 “hard-nosed” property people and SAS.

Rory’s dancers dance into view to the strains of Nessun Dorma with Simon (?) doing a poor voice over. After a few words from Jadine, Simon came on. He made a reasonable sales presentation and took a few questions but it all felt “Apprentice Lite” until Kristina made her sales presentation.

Now I know this is TV and they may well have cut these sales presentations to make the decision that SAS was about to make better TV but from what we saw of her presentation, Kristina was more impactful, she seemed to have better content and she seemed more structured and thought through. Certainly SAS’s nods, smiles and (even a) thumbs up would imply that he was thinking that way too…

Back in the board room, and after SAS has dismissed the ex-Apprentices, SAS talked to Nick and Margaret.

Nick thinks Kristina will slog her guts out for SAS all day long. He thinks Simon may well get distracted. Margaret thinks Kristina is more focused, more mature and can be left to get on with things. From what we have seen I think we can add to that the fact that she has more business acumen too.

But this is SAS TV and only he is going to deliver the final verdict. No room for sales training lessons now. What is he going to decide?

After a build up about how difficult this decision is he commends them both saying that they are both employable. They both make final pleas about what they can offer SAS and the ball is with SAS…

He tells Kristina that she has the background and the experience and Simon that he is a risk but the devil in him won’t let him go…

“Simon do you know what a bloody old fool I am, I am going to take that risk. Simon you’re hired.”

Wow! Certainly not the decision that I would have made…

Was it the right one?

Only time will tell. I’m sure Simon will work hard and get some great results and he certainly really wanted the role. But so did Kristina and I think I would have put my money into her!

Why not let me know what you guys think? Click on comments and post your thoughts.


Gavin Ingham is an author and motivational speaker specialising in sales training and business growth. Gavin has helped tens of thousands of salespeople, business owners and entrepreneurs to increase their sales and build the businesses that they desire.

Check out Gavin’s powerful books, audios & DVDs & make sure that you join his free Success newsletter.

If you want to set your next conference, AGM or away day alight then call Gavin’s team now on +44 (0) 845 838 5958. To syndicate any of Gavin’s articles or to find out about having Gavin write something for your magazine or newsletter then contact us now.


Filed under In the media, Management & leadership, Motivation & mindset by

Permalink Print Comment

Comments on The Sales Apprentice: Sales training tips from the hit TV show, The Final »

June 14, 2007

Luke @ 12:47 am

Irrespective of how credible any of the candidates were, SAS had to pick one of them (he must rue the fact that the people he’d really like to get for £100k earn far more elsewhere).

Earlier in the series he’d said he wanted someone to come up with ideas for where his businesses could go next. I thought Kristina’s answer to SAS’s question “Why should I hire you?” pigeon-holed her as a salesman and overlooked his earlier comment. Simon perhaps has the imagination to deliver that. Every business needs excellent sales teams and Kristina will doubtless have worked very hard and done very well. Simon presumably can deal with a broad range of disciplines but he clearly lacks self-confidence and evidently needs a rocket up his backside. Kristina will perform immediately but perhaps is less versatile. Simon is characteristically an apprentice and said as much (”the accomplished versus the apprentice”) in the follow up show on BBC2.

On another note, I find it extraordinary that nobody learns from previous series - let alone displays any common sense - and bones up on SAS’s businesses. Does no one research the companies they want to work for anymore? An interview should be a chance to find out about whether this is an organisation and culture the candidate wants to be a part of but there is a level of knowledge it is reasonable to assume they will go to interview with.

Andy Smith @ 3:09 am

The real lesson of this episode for me is that you can be the best candidate, do the best presentation, have the most attractive offer - and still not get the deal because the customer/boss/client/training participant or whatever has their own perception of reality that you can never fully understand. Sometimes people just make daft decisions (SAS did it last year as well by not giving the job to the Badger) and it doesn’t reflect on you, so you shouldn’t allow it to knock your confidence.

The real question for you as a person committed to your own development is “how do you tell the difference between these times and the times when you genuinely have lost the sale because of something you’ve done, but don’t realise it?”

The best thing to do, I think, is ask yourself “What do I need to learn from this?” whenever you hit a setback. And make sure you allow some time and space for the answers to emerge. If you genuinely don’t get any answers at the end of this process, maybe it is just one of those daft decisions by the customer.

Tony Brook @ 8:44 am

Hi Gavin,
I’ve enjoyed reading your thoughts on the apprentice during the series - thanks for sharing them.
I agree with you - I wouldn’t have hired Simon, in my opinion Christina won the competition which in essence was one of leadership. She also proved herself to be, shrewd, determined, a good seller and manager of people - it was in fact to all available criteria a complete whitewash in christina’s favour.
Staggering then that Simon was chosen - simon the comedy candidate in my view. Academically intelligent, thorough and the odd wild idea - a bit of a ‘plant’ to use Meredith Belbin’s terminology. A hopless leader, terrible presenter (contrary to his self appraised status - with amazingly went unchallenged throughout the whole series, he even somehow recovered from the ‘trampoline leg’ incident - unreal) I saw a guy who was well planned but not a good presenter - its true that planning and preperation is important as is delivery. Simons delivery was poor - he mainly communicated nervernous and uncertainty and was shocking under the pressure of questions where he appeared to become even more nervous.
So Simon’s weaknesses:- a poor leader, terrible at manageing people (he looked uncomfortable and desperate when attemting to guide and provide direction for his team), unconvincing seller, easlily led by dominant personalitlies (his claims that really he was masterminding his subservient role with Tre - laughable, not only was he being steered by another, this lost him credibility with the rest of his team - not that he had much in the first place.
I think sir alan has made a tremendous mistake - Simon is a risk, likely to share some traights with Clive Sinclair - may have the odd good idea (although I dont remember any inspiring creative ideas, in fact he would have gone with the boat idea in the final had the others not objected) - I find it easy to imagine him going bust chasing some loony idea (sinclair C5 perhaps) and I find it difficult to imagine him coming up with a genious idea like the ZX81.
He may be relatively creative (compared to some of the others) and he was prepared to take risks (stupid ones usually - his hunches were terrible, clearly has no idea of what everyday people are thinking and feeling).
If Sir alan wants risk takers he could hire a professional gambler - if he wants creativity he could hire a genuine creative.
So why hire him?
Was Sir alan swayed by simons hero worship and in depth knowlege of him perhaps - a little vanity creeping in?
Maybe he see’s a bit of ‘intelligent’ clay that he can mould the way he wants to - simon does seem loyal and this was clearly improtant to sir alan.
Whatever his reasons are I don’t share them in fact I would have fired simon after the QVC affair.
What does everyone else think?

Tony Brook @ 8:51 am

PS look forward to seeing Katie in panto lol- actually she’d probably make a good journalist/critic

Leave a Comment

Subscribe without commenting


Power Canvassing audio. Eliminate fear and master the art of cold calling.

Get it now.